While heat treatment improves the functionality and application of knives for their intended purposes, acid etching finishes the process.
However, some knife brands and users only acid etch their knives to improve the looks and aesthetic appeal of the blade. I stay away from such brands.
So, why do you need to acid etch a knife other than achieving some desirable looks?
Acid etching a knife can help improve the feel of the blade after heat treatment and prevent rust. Using the Ferric process, for example, creates the formation of a patina that slows down the formation of iron rust even though the corrosion resistance is lowered.
Read on to find out more about acid etching a knife and why you should care.
Table of Contents
What Does Acid Etching Do to Metal?
There are different acid etching processes and they will have various effects on the steel.
Overall, all forms of acid etching will leave an aesthetic appeal on the knife blade if done right. By filling some parts of the knife surface with acid or leaving some areas blank, an image can be etched on the surface of the knife.
While acid etching is known to wash away some of the surface metal, specific processes can boost the resistance to corrosion of the metal also.
Forced Patina Vs Acid Etching: What’s the Difference?
Although not used in the same breath, the forced patina is a method of acid etching.
Some knives start forming a patina pattern after they’ve been used for a long time. This uncontrolled aging of the blade could turn out with a beautiful design, or just show that the blade has seen some usage and time already.
As a knife user, you might want to have such a patina on your knife without waiting for all the time it would take to use the knife and get there.
Thus, you can accelerate the aging process of the knife with acids, forcing the patina to appear faster than normal.
With that, acid etching and forced patina are not different. They are both different means, with one (forced patina) being a subcategory of the other, but they generate similar ends.
Likewise, forced patina is usually practiced on carbon stainless steel blades. Ordinary stainless steel won’t patina much under this model and would be best applied to acid etching instead.
Does Acid Etching Prevent Rust on A Knife?
I have discussed over ten unique methods for removing rust from a knife, and how to prevent it in the first place.
In that piece, I didn’t mention acid etching at all. But does it work?
There is a lot of argument and proof to suggest that acid etching exposes the ‘pores’ of the knife steel, making it more susceptible to allowing moisture into the inner grains. Thus, the knife will suffer a higher risk of rust.
Another explanation for this is that acid etching roughens the surface of the knife blade metal and creates a higher surface area which reduces the corrosion resistance level of the blade.
However, there are some cases where this is not true.
For example, when the acid-resistant material used for this process is ferric, there is the formation of a red Fe3O4 patina which is more stable than red rust Fe2O3 and thus, prevents the formation of the latter.
Note that this is just one case and forms the exception, not the rule.
What Acid Is Used to Etch A Knife?
There are a series of acid etching processes that can work fine for your knife.
However, not all acids are great. To say that in a better way, not all etching acids are great for your application.
There are different kinds of steel and they will react with different acids in different ways. Thus, make sure to know the kind of stainless steel material you are working with before you choose an acid for it.
Likewise, make sure you have researched how that kind of acid might react with the steel that you have chosen.
That said, acids do not come in the same concentration level. Some (such as the Hydrochloric acid – HCl) occur as strong acids naturally while you get citric acids as a less powerful one.
While both of these acid classes will work well for etching a knife, the acid strength will also contribute to the quality of the etching outcome.
That said, guess what acid is mostly used in etching knives?
Ferric chloride is highly applicable with etching a wide variety of steel knives. This acid is preferred because it leaves desirable results, is easy to procure, and can help protect the knife against rust after the etching process.
However, the ferric chloride acid should never be used on aluminum knives or materials due to the risk of a lethal reaction that could form as a result.
Precautions to Take When Etching Knives
When dealing with acids of any kind, you need to be very careful.
Even weak acids can be deadly in the right concentrations, so you don’t want to take any chances.
Before you get started at all, and during the process, make sure of these:
- You have researched the kind of stainless steel or knife metal you are working with
- You know the right kind of acid to use
- You have your protective gear in place (e.g., gloves, face gear, boots, lab coat, etc)
- You have a well-ventilated workspace planned out
- Understand the right amount of time to expose your knives to the acid. Leave the knife for too long and it gets darker. It loses more metal as well
How to Acid Etch Your Knives at Home
Customizing your knife to give it a new look and make it more personal is a fine thing to do.
Knives are already great tools and you can make them more personal with acid etching.
Even though you still have to research your knife and follow the precautions above, you can get an idea on acid etching your knives in the video guide below:
Should You Acid Etch Your Kitchen Knives?
What you have on that knife is an acid coating that has interacted with the base metal such that the color changed. Depending on how you carried out the process, you might be able to get specific patterns in there.
No matter which it is, the coating will flake off with usage. Not all at once, but in such small quantities that you won’t see it.
Given that different food items can be acidic or alkaline also, you cannot tell what will react with your knife in a bad way. I don’t care about the knife now as much as about you, so you don’t want any of such chemical reactions near your meals.
In short, keep the forced patina and acid etch practices for knives that you EDC with and take outdoors. If you want special patterns on your kitchen knives, get yourself a Damascus knife instead.